First Meeting with a Mentor

Congratulations. You sent the message. They said yes. You have a coffee chat or a video call scheduled with someone whose career you admire.

Now the real work begins. The first meeting sets the tone for the entire relationship. If you show up unprepared, you will waste their time and yours. If you come ready with thoughtful questions and a clear idea of what you want, you will make a great impression and likely earn a second meeting.

This guide will walk you through exactly how to prepare for that first conversation. We will cover a sample agenda, the best questions to ask, and what to do after the meeting to keep the relationship alive.

Do not show up to a mentoring meeting without doing some basic research on the person you are meeting. This is not about being creepy. It is about showing respect for their time.

Spend fifteen to twenty minutes looking at their LinkedIn profile. Read their recent posts if they share content. Understand their career path. What companies have they worked at? What roles have they held? What projects have they worked on?

Also, think about what you want to get out of this meeting. Be specific. Vague goals lead to vague conversations. Here are some examples of specific goals:

- I want advice on whether I should pursue a masters degree or focus on getting industry certifications.

- I want to understand what skills I need to develop to move from a junior developer to a senior developer within two years.

- I want feedback on my current career path and whether I am on the right track.

- I want to learn about career options outside of my current field that might be a good fit for my skills.

Write down your goal before the meeting. It will help you stay focused.

Most first mentoring meetings should be thirty minutes. That is enough time to have a meaningful conversation without overstaying your welcome. Here is a sample agenda you can follow.

First 5 minutes: Warm up and context

Thank them for their time. Give a thirty second summary of who you are and what you do. Remind them why you wanted to meet with them specifically. Keep this short. They already know why you are there.

Next 20 minutes: Questions and conversation

This is the main part of the meeting. Ask your prepared questions. Listen carefully. Take notes if that helps you. Do not be afraid to ask follow up questions or ask for clarification.

Last 5 minutes: Next steps and thank you

Ask if they would be open to a follow up conversation in a few months. Ask if there is anyone else they think you should talk to. Thank them again for their time. End on time. Do not let the meeting run over unless they explicitly say they have more time.

Not all questions are created equal. Bad questions are vague and could be answered by a quick Google search. Good questions are specific and show that you have done your homework.

Here are some of the best questions you can ask a mentor in a first meeting:

About their career path:

- What was the most important decision you made early in your career?

- What do you wish you had known when you were at my stage?

- Was there a moment when you felt like giving up? What kept you going?

About your specific situation:

- I am trying to decide between [Option A] and [Option B]. How would you think through this decision?

- What skills do you think will be most valuable in our field over the next five years?

- If you were in my position today, what would you focus on?

About their industry or field:

- What trends are you seeing that most people are not paying attention to?

- What is the biggest challenge facing our industry right now?

- Who else in this space do you admire and why?

For referrals and next steps:

- Is there anyone else you think I should talk to?

- Are there any resources like books, podcasts, or courses you would recommend?

- Would you be open to meeting again in a few months?

Avoid questions like what advice do you have for someone starting out. That is too broad. Be specific about what you actually need help with.

There are a few common mistakes that can ruin a first mentoring meeting. Avoid these at all costs.

Do not ask for a job. This is not a job interview. Asking for a job in the first meeting makes things awkward and puts the mentor in an uncomfortable position. The goal is to build a relationship, not to get a referral on the spot.

Do not complain about your current job or boss. Venting feels good in the moment but it reflects poorly on you. Keep the conversation positive and forward looking.

Do not dominate the conversation. You should talk less than your mentor. Listen more than you speak. Ask questions and then actually listen to the answers.

Do not be late. Show up on time or even a couple of minutes early. If something comes up, message them as soon as possible to let them know.

Do not forget to follow up. Sending a thank you message after the meeting is not optional. It is a basic courtesy that shows you value their time.

The meeting is over. But the relationship is just beginning. What you do after the meeting matters just as much as what you did during it.

Within 24 hours, send a thank you message. Keep it short and specific. Here is a template you can use:

Subject: Thank you for your time today

Hi [Name],

Thank you again for taking the time to meet with me today. I really appreciated your perspective on [specific thing you discussed].

You mentioned [something specific they said]. I have been thinking about that and it has already changed how I am approaching [related thing].

I will follow up on [something you agreed to do]. And I would love to take you up on your offer to meet again in a few months if you are still open to it.

Thanks again for your generosity.

Best,

[Your Name]

This kind of follow up does two things. It shows that you were paying attention. And it shows that you are serious about acting on their advice. Both of those things make people want to help you more.

One meeting does not make a mentoring relationship. Real mentoring happens over time. It is built on trust, mutual respect, and consistent communication.

Here are some ways to keep the relationship alive after the first meeting:

Send updates. If you acted on their advice, let them know how it went. People love to see that their input made a difference.

Share interesting articles or resources. If you come across something relevant to their work or interests, send it their way. This shows that you are thinking about them beyond just your own needs.

Check in every few months. You do not need to meet constantly. A quick message every two or three months is usually enough to stay on their radar.

Offer value in return. Mentoring does not have to be one way. Think about what you can offer. Maybe you are good at social media. Maybe you can help with research. Maybe you can introduce them to someone in your network. Small gestures go a long way.

Remember that most mentors do not expect anything in return. But showing that you are thoughtful and appreciative will make them want to continue helping you.

Sometimes the chemistry is just not there. Maybe the mentor was distracted or not very engaged. Maybe you felt awkward and could not find your rhythm. It happens.

Do not let one bad meeting discourage you. Not every potential mentor will be a good fit. That is okay. Thank them for their time and move on to the next person on your list.

The goal is not to get every potential mentor to like you. The goal is to find one or two people who are genuinely interested in helping you grow. That takes time and a bit of trial and error.

So keep going. Keep reaching out. Keep showing up prepared. Eventually you will find your people.

© Copyright SCWIST 2026
MakePossible was created by SCWIST
(Society for Canadian Women in Science and Technology)
With project funding support from Women and Gender Equality Canada

The MakePossible community provides a great opportunity to learn and gain insight from our Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) and further support from other community members and mentors. Although some resources may be shared on our behalf, MakePossible is in no way providing formal advice for your professional or personal matters. Please use your own discretion when consulting any of the materials shared here.